April 21, 2005
David Brooks, Meet Medusa
by Lorraine Berry

Medusa would like to kick your ass today, Mr. Brooks. I don't often wish for supergirl powers, but today, I'd like to be able to use my superpowers to turn you into a woman. A poor woman. A poor woman living in a county where there are no abortion providers. Oh, and I'd make you about 15. With a daddy who can't keep his hands to himself. I'd make you frightened, and helpless, and wishing that someone would help you figure out what to do.
If I was Medusa, Mr. Brooks, I'd turn your man parts to stone, make 'em inoperable. That way, you wouldn't be able to get any woman pregnant. Of course, that wouldn't stop you from spouting off about how it's all the fault of uppity women that our political system is a fucking personal destruction free-for-all. So, I guess as Medusa, I'd have to turn your head to stone, too. Of course, I wouldn't have to do anything about your heart. Turning it to stone would be a redundancy.
How do you sleep at night, Mr. Brooks? Do they pay you well, those good ol' boys that you defended this morning? The party of mass destruction, of the mean daddies who want their own fucking way all the time, the ones who have been taking a sledgehammer to the Constitution in an effort to keep themselves in power, what exactly is it that you owe them?
Do you have any idea what it was like for women before legalized abortion? Have you walked through a graveyard, counted the headstones that bear the names of too many women who died young, of the infants who were often buried with them? Are you really that blind?
Who will you blame next? Lyndon Johnson said when he signed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 that the Democrats would lose the south for a generation. Well, they've lost it for more than that. And it was still the right thing to do. The politics of personal destruction is not the fault of Rosa Parks or Dr. King, and it damn well is not the fault of Harry Blackmun and the Supreme Court of 1973.
There is passion, and then there is stone-cold cynicism. Mr. Brooks today I have felt its icy blast. I guess I have no need to be Medusa today. You sir, are an unfeeling rock.
Photo credit: Mark Beazley, mbeaz@aol.com
Posted by in Abortion, Bio-Power, Body, Christian Fundamentalism, Civil Rights, Culture War, Culture of Life, Democracy, Empire, Extremists, Fascism, Identity Politics, Journalism, Law, Liberalism, Politics, Poverty, Prejudice, Reproductive Rights, Republicans, Roe vs. Wade, Sex, Sexual Politics, Supreme Court
Permalink |
Comments (4)
| TrackBack (0) | Technorati Cosmos
Trackbacks
Trackback for this post:http://www.culturekitchen.com/cgi-bin/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/2906
The following blogs make reference to this post :
Say it loud, say it proud!
Lorraine, my dear, you rock! As usual!
2
Comment by: Aaron Barlow at April 22, 2005 07:31 AM
I tried to read that Brooks column--and was too disgusted to finish.
Thanks, Lorraine.
What drivel he produces!
3
Comment by: Elisa Camahort at April 22, 2005 10:39 AM
Oh God. The Brooks column was a horrible way to start my morning yesterday.
What happened to Republicans and their sober message of responsibility and accountability? What happened to their belief in keeping government out of your business? Oh, wait...it's the Democrats who care about stuff like that!
I wrote my own rant on Brooks here:
http://sccdp.org/blogentry.php?linkID=http://sccdcc.mn.sabren.com/mt-static/archives/issues/001437.html
4
Comment by: Carolyn at April 22, 2005 04:05 PM
I sent him this email... what a dick!
Dear David Brooks,
Your piece entitled, "Roe's Birth, and Death" was drawn to my attention by a friend (a blogger, even!) and I feel so forced to respond to your insanity but don't quite know what to say. I have seen you on TV a few times and always thought you were intelligent, certainly, but playing ball for the wrong team as it were. But in this piece, I am forced to question your intelligence entirely! You suggest that Roe v. Wade should be overturned to protect Minority rights? Are you kidding me? Look, the bottom line is, no one is ever going to force one of those closed-minded hicks to get an abortion, so her rights (and I say her because I honestly don't care what the related slack-jawed men think) are never going to be violated. Period.
Unless women are assured the right to have, or not have an abortion - AS THEY CHOOSE - we will all be screwed.
From a pro-choice Mom-to-be,
Carolyn Castiglia Vink


1
Comment by: Mary Julia at April 22, 2005 12:07 AM