mole333's picture

No...you are wrong

I have read the Thirteenth Tribe and you completely misrepresent Koestler's thesis. He argues that a part of Ashkenazi Jewish heritage comes from the collapsed kingdom of Khazaria...something I have written about quite often, actually. He never argues that Jews in general (including Sabras, the Jews who ALWAYS have live in Israel, or Sephardim) are descendents of the Khazars or even that all Ashkenazim are descendents of the Khazars. Koestler himself was a Zionist, for that matter.

I have read many genetic studies in the scientific literature and they ALL indicate that Jews from all over the world are closely related not only to eachother, but also to the Palestinians. Palestinians are more related to the Jews than they are to the Arabs, who are also closely related to both. THAT makes all those groups Semites. If Jews don't belong there then neither do the Palestinians and visa versa. Truth is, genetic, archaeological and historical evidence all point to both Palestinians AND Jews being descendents of the native Canaanites, though both have mixed with other groups throughout their history.

Don't base your conclusions based on only one or two sources. I base my conlcusions on genetics (Palestinians and Jews, including Ashkenazim EXCEPT Askenazi Levites, are closely related), archaeology (both cultures evolved out of the native Canaanite culture), history (the earliest records of Israel and the Philistines indicate a contemporary evolution) and international law (regardless of origins both nations were created out of the ashes of the Ottoman Empire by the same legal mechanism and have equal legal basis). I suggest broadening your mind and your reading.


Reply

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may link to webpages through the weblinks registry
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.
  • Easily link to terms in various wikis. For help, see interwiki.
  • Images can be added to this post.
More information about formatting options

Visit our sponsors

Fill up our coffee fund

BlogAds

Buy it!


Visit our sponsors

Get our Digestifs du jour

Nibble daily on our brainy goodness with our daily syndication digest. You'll receive an email with a list and links to the previous day's posts.



Powered by FeedBlitz

culturekitchens

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Daily servings of political dissent
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers
Network

BlogSheroes

A new kind of vouyerism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] culturekitchen [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Member's articles and stories

More stories

Google Ads

The Big Dialog


Who's online

There are currently 1 user and 1254 guests online.

Online users

Instant Congress

Don't know your Senators or US Representatives' phone numbers?
Enter your street address and zip code and find out right now.
Street number and name only:
Zip Code (5 digits):


Upcoming events

  • no upcoming events available

Words to live by

"When a religion is good, I conceive it will support itself; and when it does not support itself, and God does not take care to support it so that its professors are obliged to call for help of the civil power, 'tis a sign, I apprehend, of its being a bad one."


— -- Benjamin Franklin, letter to Richard Price, October 9, 1780, quoted from Adrienne Koch, ed., The American Enlightenment: The Shaping of the American Experiment and a Free Society, New York: George Braziller, 1965, p. 93.


Subscribe Buttons

Feed IconGoogleDeliciousYahoo!BloglinesNewsgatorMSNFeedsterAOLFurlRojoNewsburstPluckFeedFeedsAdd KinjaMultiRSSrMailRSSFwdBlogarithmSimplify