Who could have imagined that in the United States, with its independent judiciary, thousands of men could be rounded up in the night -- many only because of their Muslim religion or foreign nationality -- without recourse to a trial, without even an acknowledgment that they had been arrested? Who could have dared to suggest that there would ever be "desaparecidos" in America? And there it was as well, torture being discussed as a legitimate option to protect a community in peril, and then being used in Guantanamo and Afghanistan, and even obscenely photographed in Iraq -- yes, there they were again, the depressing echoes of my Chile.
But worse perhaps than all of this was the erosion of the moral compass of America, the seeming indifference of the seeming majority to the suffering of others, the casual acceptance of "collateral damage" as an unquestioned consequence of the war on "terrorism," the demonization of an ubiquitous foe who had to be destroyed without second thoughts -- and often without first ones as well; without, in fact, any thoughtfulness at all. That was far more terrifying than the criminal attacks on New York and Washington: To realize that the Chile of strongman Augusto Pinochet was not that far away, not that difficult to imitate, that it was already hovering in the future and ready to materialize if we were not vigilant.
Good analysis
I have already decided on John Edwards.
Your analysis is quite well done. I was particularly interested in your comments on some of the subtleties of his speech and plans. I think these are things I take for granted. You may be very correct when you assert that some miss them. Certainly the media misses them... if they report on Edwards at all.
A couple of things I want to add.
An important and much missed aspect of John Edwards' campaign is his ability to focus on the important things. For example, all of the candidates knew that health care was, and continues to be, a major issue for all Americans, yet none came to the campaign with a thorough, well thought out plan to introduce universal health coverage. Senator Edwards did.
Another thing that I admire about the Senator is his willingness to address causes. Addressing poverty, education, health, government influence peddling, and government corporatization are among the most important causes that negatively impact the quality of life here in the United States and around the world.
I didn't put corporatization at the head of the list although cases can be made that this is the prevalent cause. Considering the ownership of the Federal Reserve, etc., I can hear the corporatists now, to paraphrase an old commercial, "It's not nice to fool corporate interests."
John Edwards is willing to take these people on. Though he states that you don't invite them to the table because they eat all the food, I think he might invite them once they're muzzled. Corporate interests do have a role in our quality of life, just not the "only" role as those interests constantly promote.