The Pasta God, Blind Faith in School and Juicy-Fruit Holiday Slobbers

Liza gave us little plastic bricks rather than edible eggs and peeps for Easter, but now the Pastafarians present (entirely in Legos) the amazing Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster!

Thus edible faith has now been rendered in the true building blocks of the universe, Legos, which although not edible, do multiply miraculously like the symbolic foods of the faithful -- Legos are limitless fishes and loaves in every room of OUR house, how about yours?

I've always had transcendent faith in food as holy, in chefs and chocolatiers as divine. My own most enduring ritual of faith is devouring human creativity in any form it presents itself. I'm not such an omnivore as Anthony Bourdain and his extreme cuisine -- his favorite eggs are the eggs of sea urchins, not exactly conducive to the traditional holiday rituals I know! -- but I do enjoy a variety of foods and well-rendered cultural infusions and combinations, and as you'd expect now that you're getting to know me, I especially savor the stories BEHIND the food.

[quote=Chef Bourdain]
[Food faith failures] usually get the décor slavishly right and then screw up everything else . . . They have too much attitude, which is exactly what a real bistro shouldn’t have. . . they tend to Americanize the menu or recipes in a cowardly way – afraid that the real thing won’t sell and that their customers are too stupid or unsophisticated to know or “get it” if they do it the right way.[/quote]

Which made me think of the dispute about the right way to cook for Thanksgiving, another religious holiday with competing cultural stories, full of quarreling over blind faith as expressed through visions of food.

Last year, the Times printed a Thanksgiving column by James E. McWilliams, Texas State University history professor, based on his book, "A Revolution in Eating: How the Quest for Food Shaped America."

(Our) Puritan forebears migrated to New England with strict
notions about food production and preparation . . . demand(ing) that flesh be domesticated, grain neatly planted and fruit and vegetables cultivated in gardens and orchards.

Given these expectations, English migrants recoiled upon discovering that the native inhabitants hunted their game, grew their grain haphazardly and foraged for fruit and vegetables. . . From the colonists' perspective, Native Americans grew crops in an entirely corrupt manner. . .the English, blinded by tradition, never got it - they just looked on in horror.

Where were the fences? The neat rows of cross-sectioned grain? The plows? Where were the carts of dung? The team of oxen? The yokes? Why were perfectly good trees left to rot? Why not burn them to power a fireplace? And those fish! Why not salt them down and export them to Europe for a tidy profit? What was wrong with these people?

A similar culinary misunderstanding developed over meat. . .
To resort to the hunt was, after all, indicative of agricultural failure, poor planning and laziness.

Culturally stuffed with story as Christmas approached, I came across a feature about fruit as religious Power of Story, which --what else?-- made me think of apples and oranges as the perennial fruit of every dispute among the education faithful.

If I had a pomegranate for every time I've heard scornful schoolfolk and other literalists use "no, no, that's comparing apples to oranges" as a new story or idea slap-down, I'd have . . . hmm . . . a veritable orchard of juicy ideas?

"FRUITS OF FAITH: Pomegranates burst with symbolism for believers of many creeds"
(as seen in the Miami Herald)

Next time you're in the produce aisle, pick up a pomegranate and treat yourself to a lesson in world religions. Beneath that smooth, bitter, red skin lie hundreds of tiny scarlet seeds -- and almost as many religious associations.

''People use whatever is at hand to express their religious beliefs,'' says Frank A. Salamone, an authority on religious symbols and a professor at Iona College in New Rochelle, N.Y. Centuries ago in the Fertile Crescent, where so many faiths arose, the pomegranate was at hand, and, by its very nature, lent itself to religious symbolism.

''The pomegranate is red, and so is blood,'' Salamone says. ``It has a lot of seeds and is an obvious symbol of fertility,". . . beautiful, strong and delicate, he adds, and its juice is exceptionally healthful.

``It says a lot of different things all at once. People bring meaning to it.''

PEOPLE bring meaning to IT. Did you catch that ripened hint of saucy impertinence?

Some fruit in our cultural orchard is just rotten, of course. Calling other folks fruits for instance, even when you mean it Biblically, is rotten as story or truth, fermented fruit that may feel intoxicating when sipped, but leads to thoughtless abandon and inevitably stinks of decline and death, not life and discovery and true knowledge.

[Senator Brownback] shakes his head in sorrow, thinking of Sweden. “You’ll know ’em by their fruits.”

Conversation stalls – he’s citing scripture but we both know he just said “fruits,” about gay Swedes. . .
(and) since discussion of the article has stalled on the word fruits, I want to jumpstart it. I always write more than I use, and what gets cut usually never sees the light of day, for good reason. But for religion writers, some of the outtakes may be more interesting than the story itself. . .

Well, the apple in the Garden of Eden was a "bad" apple in the Bible story, wasn't it? The Tree of Knowledge, oooh - too dangerous, too ugly, too powerful! -- no wonder fundamental Christians are suspicious of "school" and its fruit.

They believe the fruit story of Genesis is literally true and fixed in meaning, not just something to think about and try to build new meaning from, through their own lives, like one Lego piece in a multi-colored closetful. (Wonder what my life would look like in Legos?)

The Gnostic Gospels and the Gospel of Judas make tasty outtakes from the Bible's writers, that's for sure! Truth be told, although I write about a different kind of faith -- faith in thinking and knowing -- I often find my own outtakes so interesting that I can't actually LEAVE them out, and sneak to incorporate them as comments. Maybe this outtakes-are-tasty rule of thumb is a crosscultural recipe, true for writers, readers and party planners of all cuisines?

In any case, do you think there could be "new" truth in this ancient faith-in-fruit power of story stuff, too?
Let's give it a squeeze and see how fresh the juices are --

We use apples to prove that The Doctor (unquestioned authority) is always right and to prescribe standardized accountability based on counting out one per day per person, while oranges have individually irregular navels (nature and motherhood as life itself) and dimpled skin that lends itself to enthusiastic "zesting" by hand - so obviously the whole "apples and oranges" frame represents the eternal conflict between public school and private home!

Maybe we could look to those culture-clashing forebears of ours for a mid-story change in course that might lead to a happier ending?

[quote=As our friendly food historian]
. . . these [previously shocking] foods became celebrated as a reflection of emerging ideals like simplicity, manifest destiny and rugged individualism.

. . .we proudly evoke this native American heritage by crowding the table with turkey, corn, stuffing, cranberry sauce and pumpkin pie as if they had always been there.

That they weren't shouldn't be a cause for chagrin, but a reminder that Americans have survived in some measure because we are endlessly adaptable and capable of overcoming our deepest prejudices -
even if the Pilgrims wouldn't have approved.[/quote]


http://culturekitchen.com/jj_ross/story/the_pasta_god_blind_faith_in_school_and_juicy_
Mouse over the text to select it, then press Ctrl-C to copy it.
JJ Ross's picture



Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
blog comments powered by Disqus ">
JJ Ross's picture

Taking Food Seriously

is Michael Pollan's new NYT blog entry, a news journalist writing about food being connected to hard news as The Revealer site features real journalism about faith.

I'm starting Pollan's latest book now, and I have Dr. Nestle's Food Politics in my stack, considered new-found "gospel" it seems.

From Pollan's blog:

Whenever I’m in the company of other journalists and the conversation turns to our respective beats, mine — food — usually draws a silent snicker. It’s deemed a less-than-serious subject, and I suppose compared to covering war or national security, it can be viewed that way. . .
Excuse me, but are you not dependent on the stuff?

This disdain for food journalism has several springs. One of them surely is sexism . . .

“When we try to pick out anything by itself,” John Muir once wrote, “we find it hitched to everything else in the universe.”
. . . As William Ralph Inge, the English essayist, wrote early in the last century, “all of nature is a conjugation of the verb to eat, in the active and passive.”

. . . Food connects us to nature, first and foremost, but it also attaches us to all the other large systems that organize our lives — from energy and economics to politics, public health and cultural identity.

In recent years we’ve all come to appreciate the critical links between oil and things like the health of our economy and the conduct of our foreign policy. Crises have a way of laying bare such connections. . . During the last 50 years we’ve been living in a kind of fool’s food paradise, marked by astounding bounty and apparent choice.

In his farewell press conference as outgoing Secretary of Homeland Security, Tommy Thompson broke the silence on this threat once again: “For the life of me, I cannot understand why the terrorists have not attacked our food supply because it is so easy to do.”

. .. We see every day how our dependence on foreign energy has crippled our foreign policy. Imagine how much more debilitating a dependence on foreign food would be. Make no mistake, how we feed ourselves is about to become a national security issue.


blog comments powered by Disqus ">
JJ Ross's picture

MFK Fisher

simply MUST be mentioned in this context!

Lynn on MFK Fisher's "The Art of Eating"

JJ (this one, not Lynn's husband) on MFK Fisher as true portrait of a First Lady


blog comments powered by Disqus ">
JJ Ross's picture

Omnivore's Dilemma

An interview with Pollan is featured in the current (May 2006) issue of The Sun Magazine, in which he says our cognitive and cultural tools for figuring out what to eat have been turned against us by industry.

There’s a huge amount of confusion right now about what to eat, and people want to be more conscious of what they’re eating, either because of their health or because they care about the natural world and animals.

People want to do the right thing.
What the right thing is, however,
depends on what you value.


blog comments powered by Disqus ">
JJ Ross's picture

"Ask MisEducation"

blog comments powered by Disqus ">
JJ Ross's picture

Da Vinci Code Opening Day

One great thing about unschooling is that the kids and I can easily see new movies on opening weekdays, at 11 am or 1:30 pm or whenever, without lines or crowds or even other kids around.

Favorite Daughter (our comparative religion buff) just spent the past 36 hours reading the Da Vinci Code, finishing last night, and so we're going in a few minutes. Last night we sat together and watched Chris Matthews interviewing the head of Opus Dei in the NY headquarters, marveling at all the PR swirling around this on all sides.

It will be interesting to see how the 10-year-old takes this all in, never having read either Dan Brown or the Bible.

He sure is enjoying the Gospel of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, though - and grasping its satire on more levels than even I'd expected he would.

So I think it's time to start admitting our culture is often more educational out of school than in. Movie review (from that viewpoint) to come this evening -- JJ
Smiling


blog comments powered by Disqus ">
JJ Ross's picture

Da Vinci Code as Education

So the 10-year-old had a great time, thought the movie was just like National Treasure. He appreciated the intrigue more than I'd expected, and how players on all sides got blinded by their own belief, not in any superpower but in their own power to be RIGHT - and their right to be powerful because they were so sure they were right.

Maybe kids who have gobbled up the Manichean duality of Star Wars and the more mixed up good-petty-bad-evil motive mix of Harry Potter characters, can grasp belief complexities far better than I did at their age, fed a steady diet of idealistic lies?

The 16-year-old went straight back to the bookstore before even leaving the mall, and now is immersed in her first Bart Ehrman book, "Lost Scriptures." She has a half-dozen similar books on her reading-in-waiting list, and woke up this morning to tell me how maddening it was that Mary Magdelene's gospel was missing several pages right at an intriguing part, as she was about to reveal how Jesus wanted her to set up his church! Favorite Daughter is indignant, suspects nefarious traditionalist intent has suppressed some great feminist secret now lost forever:

"[The mind between the soul and the spirit} -- that is what sees the vision, and it is . . ."

When the narrative resumes four pages later, Mary Magdelene's mind has moved on.

Don't you hate it when that happens?!
Smiling


User login

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Daily servings of political dissent
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers
Network

BlogSheroes

A new kind of vouyerism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] culturekitchen [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Nibble daily on our brainy goodness with our daily syndication digest. You'll receive an email with a list and links to the previous day's posts.



Powered by FeedBlitz

Upcoming events

  • No upcoming events available

QUOTES

Their clear and open intent is to do all they can, however they can, to sabotage the new administration (and the economy to boot). They want failure. Even now. Even after the last eight years. Even in a recession as steeply dangerous as this one. There are legitimate debates to be had; and then there is the cynicism and surrealism of total political war. We now should have even less doubt about what kind of people they are. And the mountain of partisan vitriol Obama will have to climb every day of the next four or eight years.


— Andrew Sullivan, The GOP Has Declared War On Obama


Poll