Fair Use and Net Neutrality are the same thing

So the recent struggles about network neutrality have led me to recognize something I hadn't quite seen before. And that something in turn makes more puzzling the debates that have been raised around network neutrality. The something to recognize is that in a fundamental sense, fair use (FU) and network neutrality (NN) are the same thing. They are both state enforced limits on the property rights of others. In both cases, the limits are slight --the vast range of uses granted a copyright holder are only slightly restricted by FU; the vast range of uses allowed a network owner are only slightly restricted by NN. And in both cases, the line defining the limits is uncertain. But in both cases, those who support each say that the limits imposed on the property right are necessary for some important social end (admittedly, different in each case), and that the costs of enforcing those limits are outweighed by the benefits of protecting that social end. So from this perspective, it is easy to understand those who reject FU and NN (who are they?). And it is easy to understand those who embrace FU and NN. What gets difficult is understanding those who embrace one while rejecting the other --at least when that rejection is articulated in terms of "government regulation".
liza's picture

| | | | | | |


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
JJ Ross's picture

OH! YES!

Exactly so! This is brilliantly put.

It really helps me crystallize my own thinking, how adamant my defense of Fair Use has been for decades (as an educator-researcher-librarian type) - also it parallels my exasperation and growing concerns over advocates of the individual's privacy and choice for schooling and religion, but not for deciding to have a child or not in the first place, or for that child's right to make or not make them grandparents, without public interference.

And the reverse of course, those who are so pro-choice and pro-individual privacy EXCEPT when it comes to public schooling decided by the Village and not the parent . . .

The best help I found to understand such contradictions of thought and principle, was in Ronald Dworkin's book-length argument, Life's Dominion. I wonder if his way of thinking could apply in similar fashion to this?
Or maybe he's already written about it, does anyone know? hmmm . . .


Nance Confer's picture

Net Neutrality

Huh? I thought "net neutrality" was code for telecom corporations getting to charge for faster access through their networks. Or do I have this backwards? Or is this a completely different thing?

Liza -- help!!!!! Smiling

Nance


Visit our sponsors

Upcoming events

Fill up our coffee fund

BlogAds

Buy it!


Visit our sponsors

Get our Digestifs du jour

Nibble daily on our brainy goodness with our daily syndication digest. You'll receive an email with a list and links to the previous day's posts.



Powered by FeedBlitz

culturekitchens

The Publisher
Liza Sabater

Daily servings of political dissent
culturekitchen

Grassroots News and
Activism for New Yorkers

Daily Gotham

Feminist Bloggers
Network

BlogSheroes

A new kind of vouyerism
Voogling

Art + Code + Philosophy
Potatoland.blog

Got any dirt, tips, leads or money for us? Then drop us a line or two at editors [at] culturekitchen [dot] com or use our general contact form to reach everybody in the editorial team ASAP.


Member's articles and stories

More stories

Google Ads

The Big Dialog


Who's online

There are currently 2 users and 1244 guests online.

Online users

Instant Congress

Don't know your Senators or US Representatives' phone numbers?
Enter your street address and zip code and find out right now.
Street number and name only:
Zip Code (5 digits):


Words to live by

It was the first time a person saved an air bag's life.


— Iowa Senator Tom Harkin commenting on Bob Dole's financial bail out of Newt Gingrich


Subscribe Buttons

Feed IconGoogleDeliciousYahoo!BloglinesNewsgatorMSNFeedsterAOLFurlRojoNewsburstPluckFeedFeedsAdd KinjaMultiRSSrMailRSSFwdBlogarithmSimplify